The previous post was about my house-ruled initiative rules for D&D.
I know they work, now the question is:
-do they make the game more fun?
-do they make combat, easier, more exciting, faster, etc?
-do they simplify or complicate?
Whether a house rule or a rule in a completely new game, it should always hold up to these standards. If it isn't adding anything to the game, it's worthless.
I will let the players judge when the next session comes up.